Cartel is an American rock band from Conyers, Georgia, that has carved a significant niche in the landscape of modern rock music. Emerging in the mid-2000s, the band skillfully blended elements of pop-punk, alternative rock, and emo to create a sound that resonated with a generation. Their journey from a self-released EP to mainstream success and enduring relevance is a testament to their melodic craftsmanship and resilience. This biography explores the chronological history of Cartel, their musical evolution, and their lasting impact on the rock scene, including their celebrated status at events like Emo Night Pittsburgh.
Formation and Early Era
The foundation of Cartel was laid in the suburbs of Atlanta, where a group of high school friends shared a common passion for the burgeoning rock sounds of the late 1990s and early 2000s. This early period was defined by raw energy, ambitious songwriting, and the drive to make a mark beyond their local scene.
Origins and Formation
Cartel officially formed in 2003, comprised of vocalist Will Pugh, lead guitarist Joseph Pepper, bassist Ryan Roberts, drummer Kevin Sanders, and guitarist Andy Lee. The members had known each other since their time at Heritage High School, playing in various local bands before uniting their talents. Their shared influences, which ranged from 90s alternative rock to contemporary pop-punk, created a fertile ground for their collaborative songwriting. Pugh, who had attended Georgia State University and the University of Georgia, ultimately left his studies to dedicate himself fully to the band’s future, a decision that would soon prove fruitful. The band’s initial chemistry was strong, built on years of friendship and a collective desire to pursue music professionally.
Early Discography
The band’s first formal release was The Ransom EP, a self-released effort from March 2004. The EP showcased their potential, featuring a polished yet energetic sound that caught the attention of listeners in the Atlanta music scene. Songs from this period demonstrated their knack for writing catchy hooks and emotionally resonant lyrics, cornering the market on a sound that was both commercially viable and artistically credible. Shortly after the EP’s release, founding guitarist Andy Lee departed from the band. He was replaced by Nic Hudson, a friend who nearly joined the military before receiving the invitation to join Cartel. This lineup change solidified the core group that would create their breakthrough material. Later in 2004, the band’s performance at the Atlantis Music Conference in Atlanta attracted the attention of The Militia Group, an independent record label that signed them in September and re-released The Ransom EP to a wider audience.
The Mainstream Breakthrough
Cartel’s transition from a promising independent act to a mainstream contender was swift and impactful. The release of their debut full-length album catapulted them into the national spotlight, earning them critical acclaim and a dedicated fanbase that continues to support them to this day.
Pivotal Album(s) and Lineup Changes
The pivotal moment in Cartel’s career arrived with the release of their debut studio album, Chroma, in September 2005. Recorded in just eight days with producers Zack Odom and Kenneth Mount, the album was a masterclass in pop-rock songwriting. It featured a collection of meticulously crafted tracks that balanced radio-friendly appeal with genuine emotional depth. The album’s lead single, “Honestly,” became a breakout hit, its music video receiving significant airplay on MTV and its infectious chorus becoming an anthem for the era. The success of “Honestly” drove Chroma onto the Billboard 200 chart. Following the album’s release, bassist Ryan Roberts left the band in 2006 and was replaced by Jeff Lett, marking another key lineup adjustment as the band’s profile continued to rise.
Achieving Critical and Commercial Success
Chroma was both a critical and commercial triumph. Publications like Alternative Press lauded the album, and it is frequently cited by outlets like Rock Sound and Loudwire as one of the greatest pop-punk albums of its time. The record sold over 250,000 copies, a remarkable achievement for a band on an independent label. This success led to extensive touring, including a spot on the Vans Warped Tour and support slots for major acts. The band’s live shows were praised for their energy and precision, further solidifying their reputation. The widespread appeal of Chroma ensured that Cartel’s music became a staple for any fan of the genre, and its songs remain essential tracks at any authentic Pittsburgh Emo Night.
Musical Evolution and Key Events
Following their breakthrough, Cartel navigated the pressures of newfound fame and the challenge of artistic evolution. This period was marked by ambitious projects, sonic experimentation, and the internal and external pressures that come with a successful music career.
Mid-career Albums and Sonic Shifts
In 2007, Cartel embarked on a unique and highly publicized project with MTV, “Band in a Bubble.” The band was placed inside a giant glass bubble in New York City for 20 days, during which they wrote and recorded their self-titled sophomore album in full view of the public. The resulting album, Cartel, released in August 2007, showcased a more experimental and moodier sound, with angular guitars and more complex song structures. While it debuted in the top 20 on the Billboard 200, the album received mixed reviews and represented a departure from the straightforward pop-rock of Chroma.
Their third album, Cycles (2009), released on Wind-up Records, was seen as a return to form. It blended the polished accessibility of their debut with heavier rock impulses, featuring powerful tracks like “Let’s Go” and “The Perfect Mistake.” The band’s fourth album, Collider (2013), was self-released and saw them further exploring atmospheric and melodic rock, demonstrating a mature and evolving sound.
Hiatus, Reunions, or Significant Member Departures
The years following Collider marked a period of relative quiet for the band in terms of new music, though they never officially went on hiatus. They continued to tour sporadically, focusing on anniversary shows for Chroma that drew large, enthusiastic crowds. During this time, members pursued other projects, with Will Pugh notably working as a producer for other bands, including New Found Glory. A significant lineup shift occurred when bassist Jeff Lett left in 2011 to focus on his education. Nic Hudson moved to bass before the band eventually settled with Will Pugh taking over bass duties in addition to lead vocals, bringing the band to its current four-piece configuration.
Modern Era
After a period of reflection and independent work, Cartel has re-emerged in the 2020s with renewed energy, reaffirming their status as influential figures in the pop-punk and emo scenes and connecting with both longtime fans and a new generation of listeners.
Recent Albums and Contemporary Activity
In 2022, Cartel released their first new music in nine years: the singles “17” and “The End.” These tracks showcased a refined version of their signature sound, blending nostalgic themes with their evolved musical sensibilities. The releases coincided with a major tour supporting Dashboard Confessional and Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness, reintroducing the band to large audiences across North America.
The most significant recent development is the celebration of the 20th anniversary of Chroma. In 2025, the band announced the release of Chroma – 2025, a re-recorded and reimagined version of their classic debut album, set to be released via Field Day Records. The project includes a re-sequenced tracklist to reflect the band’s original vision and guest appearances, including Cassadee Pope of Hey Monday. To support this, Cartel announced their first headlining U.S. tour in a decade, a clear signal of their continued passion and activity.
Cultural Impact and Connection to the Scene
Cartel’s influence extends beyond their record sales and chart positions. They emerged during a peak era for emo and pop-punk, and their music has become synonymous with the sound and feeling of that time, making them icons within the scene.
Influence on Their Primary Genres
Cartel’s impact on alternative rock and pop-punk is defined by their melodic sophistication and lyrical sincerity. Chroma, in particular, set a high bar for songwriting in the genre, demonstrating that it was possible to achieve mainstream appeal without sacrificing artistic integrity. They helped to bridge the gap between the raw energy of punk and the polished production of pop, influencing countless bands that followed. Their ability to craft timeless, singalong anthems has ensured their music endures, standing as a key touchstone for the mid-2000s rock movement.
Relevance in Nostalgia Events like Emo Night Pittsburgh
The enduring popularity of bands like Cartel has fueled the rise of nostalgia-themed events that celebrate the music of the 2000s. At gatherings like Emo Night Pittsburgh, Cartel’s songs are not just played; they are celebrated. Tracks like “Honestly” and “Say Anything (Else)” are guaranteed to inspire massive singalongs, acting as a powerful conduit to a specific time and feeling. For attendees of a Pittsburgh Emo Night, hearing Cartel is a core part of the experience, a reminder of the band’s undeniable and lasting cultural footprint. Their music continues to unite fans, proving that a great song transcends its era.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cartel
When did the band Cartel form?
Cartel formed in 2003 in Conyers, Georgia. The founding members were friends who knew each other from high school.
What is Cartel’s most famous album?
Cartel’s most famous and commercially successful album is their 2005 debut, Chroma. It features their hit single “Honestly” and is widely regarded as a classic of the pop-punk genre.
Who are the current members of Cartel?
The current members of Cartel are Will Pugh (lead vocals, bass), Joseph Pepper (lead guitar), Nic Hudson (rhythm guitar), and Kevin Sanders (drums).
Is Cartel still making music?
Yes. After a nine-year break from releasing new material, Cartel released two singles, “17” and “The End,” in 2022. In 2025, they are releasing Chroma – 2025, a re-recorded version of their debut album, and are embarking on a national headlining tour.
What genre of music is Cartel?
Cartel’s music is primarily categorized as pop-punk and alternative rock, with strong elements of emo. Their sound is characterized by catchy melodies, polished production, and emotionally driven lyrics.
What was the “Band in a Bubble” event?
In 2007, Cartel partnered with MTV for a highly publicized event called “Band in a Bubble.” The band lived and worked in a large glass enclosure in New York City for 20 days, writing and recording their self-titled second album in full public view.
